Local zoning · Scotts Valley

Scotts Valley — Nonconforming Uses

Nonconforming Uses under the Scotts Valley local zoning and planning code, with the controlling citations.

Ask a question free See coverage

Last reviewed: July 2, 2026

Overview

Scotts Valley treats nonconforming situations (uses, buildings/structures, and lots) in Chapter 17.48 of the Zoning Title (Title 17). The city preserves lawful pre‑existing uses/structures but restricts expansion, limits restoration after major damage, and terminates uses after specified cessation or amortization periods. The rules for repair, change, expansion, lot‑line adjustments and specific amortizations are laid out across Chapter 17.48 and related district chapters. See the definitions for nonconforming use and nonconforming structure in § 17.04.170.

How the nonconforming rules work (quick legal anchors)

  • What is a lawful nonconformity: the code defines nonconforming use, lawful and nonconforming structure, lawful in § 17.04.170.
  • Continuation allowed: existing nonconforming uses/structures may be continued unless restricted elsewhere — § 17.48.020.
  • Cessation: if the nonconforming use (building or land use) ceases for six continuous months, it may not be re‑established — § 17.48.060(A–B).
  • Repairs and alterations: ordinary nonstructural work is allowed; structural alterations are limited and often require a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) or other approval; residential nonconforming residential buildings get a limited exception — § 17.48.040.
  • Restoration from damage: if damaged more than 60% of replacement value, reconstruction must comply with current zoning; less than 60% may be restored within defined timeframes — § 17.48.070.
  • Expansion: expanding a nonconforming use requires a CUP per § 17.48.080(A) (referencing § 17.50.020 for CUP standards).
  • Lot line adjustments: allowed only where they do not increase the nonconformity — § 17.48.090.

District‑by‑district breakdown (what the code shows about districts that commonly interact with nonconformities)

Notes on format: each district name below is shown in bold and any numerical dimension or requirement is bolded; each item is tied to the specific code sections cited.

C-S (Service Commercial)

  • Purpose: The C‑S district is intended for city‑ and region‑serving, auto‑oriented commercial/service uses and to provide space for vehicle servicing, customer parking and loading (purpose statement in § 17.20.010).
  • Typical permitted uses: retail, offices, service establishments and similar uses listed in the C‑S chapter; outdoor storage is restricted/prohibited on Scotts Valley Drive and elsewhere made a conditional use (see § 17.20.035).
  • Key dimensional/development standards (decision‑relevant): Minimum lot area: 10,000 sq ft; Minimum lot width: 100 ft; Maximum building coverage: 50%; Setbacks — Front: 20 ft; Rear: 0 ft (but 20 ft if abutting an R district); Side: 0 ft (but 10 ft where adjacent to R district); Corner exterior side: 15 ft; Maximum height: 35 ft (with limited exceptions). See § 17.20.040 (A–G).
  • Where it applies: lands mapped as service commercial on the City zoning map; outdoor storage on Scotts Valley Drive is explicitly prohibited or conditioned — § 17.20.035.

Relevant nonconforming interactions: pre‑existing outdoor storage or prohibited uses are governed by Chapter 17.48 (cessation and amortization rules apply) and by the C‑S prohibition language in § 17.20.035.

(See also design‑related requirements and when design review applies for C‑P/C‑S projects.) Scotts Valley Design Review

I-L (Industrial — Light)

  • Purpose and permitted uses: The I‑L district is intended to preserve an attractive industrial area and permit light industrial activities that do not use significant hazardous materials; permitted uses are listed in § 17.26.020 and conditional uses in § 17.26.030.
  • Key dimensional/development standards: Minimum lot area: 40,000 sq ft; Minimum lot width/frontage/depth: 100 ft; Maximum building coverage: 50%; Setbacks — Front: 15 ft; Rear: 0 ft; Side: 0 ft; special yard for abutting residential/open space: 50 ft; Maximum height: 35 ft. See § 17.26.040 (A–I).
  • Where it applies: industrial parks and areas zoned I‑L per the City map.

Relevant nonconforming interactions: outdoor storage and uses adjacent to housing get extra scrutiny; design review and CUPs are used to screen new uses and expansions of nonconforming industrial uses (see § 17.26.040(N) and Chapter 17.48).

R‑1 (Single‑family residential: R‑1‑10, R‑1‑20, R‑1‑40)

  • Purpose: preserve family living and appropriate residential densities; R‑1 is divided into R‑1‑10, R‑1‑20, R‑1‑40 for density/lot size per § 17.14.010/020.
  • Typical permitted uses: single‑family dwellings, accessory uses, small family child care, transitional/supportive housing, ADUs/JADUs per Chapters 17.57/17.58 — see § 17.14.020.
  • Key dimensional standards (decision‑relevant): **R‑1‑10: Minimum lot area 10,000 sq ft; minimum width 60 ft; front yard 20 ft; side yard = 10% of lot width (max 10 ft); rear yard 15 ft. R‑1‑20: Minimum lot area 20,000 sq ft; front yard 30 ft; rear yard 15 ft. R‑1‑40: Minimum lot area 40,000 sq ft; front yard 30 ft; rear yard 20 ft. Maximum site coverage 50%; maximum structure height 35 ft (see § 17.14.040 A–F).
  • Where it applies: residential neighborhoods mapped R‑1 on the zoning map.

Relevant nonconforming interactions: accessory structures, ADUs and alterations to nonconforming homes are controlled by Chapter 17.48, accessory structure standards (Table 17.46‑1) and ADU rules (Chapter 17.57). On R‑M, R‑H and R‑VH lots occupied by a single‑family dwelling, accessory structure standards for height, floor area and maximum number are the same as in the R‑1 district — see Table 17.46‑1 notes.

R‑M, R‑H, R‑VH (Multiple‑family / higher density residential)

  • Purpose and typical uses: These districts allow multifamily and higher density housing; R‑M districts (R‑M‑6/R‑M‑8 etc.) are described in Chapter 17.12 and include multifamily dwellings and associated uses — see § 17.12.010–020.
  • Key standards: accessory structures and many yard/coverage/height limits are cross‑referenced to R‑1 standards where occupied by single‑family dwellings (see Table 17.46‑1 and notes). Multifamily ADU allowances and limits are in Chapter 17.57 (e.g., limits on number of ADUs on multifamily lots in § 17.57.060).

PD (Planned Development) / ST (Special Treatment combining) / HE and other combining districts

  • Purpose and standards: PDs are individually designed, and ST combining districts require a specific plan and added design standards; combining districts add to base zoning rules (see § 17.38, § 17.36). Nonconforming rules still apply to uses/structures within PD/ST; PDs must show the uses and standards in the general development plan (see § 17.38.020 and § 17.36.020).

Quick decision‑relevant standards / permitted uses (table)

Topic Key local rule (bold values) Code Reference
Definition of lawful nonconforming use/structure Defined as lawfully established before Title 17 change; no carving in for unlawful prior uses § 17.04.170
Continuation of existing nonconforming use May be continued except where otherwise limited § 17.48.020
Cessation period 6 continuous months — then cannot resume same nonconforming use § 17.48.060 (A–B)
Restoration after damage If > 60% of replacement value, restored only in conformance with zoning; if <60%, may be restored if started within 6 months and finished within 1 year § 17.48.070
Expansion of nonconforming use Only by Conditional Use Permit (CUP); building/structure additions reviewed by Community Development Director / Planning Commission § 17.48.080(A–B); CUP rules § 17.50.020
Lot‑line adjustments affecting nonconformities Allowed only if adjustment does not increase the nonconformity or eliminates it § 17.48.090
ADUs and nonconforming zoning conditions City shall not require correction of nonconforming zoning conditions as condition of ADU approval Chapter 17.57 (ADU standards); nonconformities clause in ADU chapter
C‑S development highlights Min lot area 10,000 sq ft; front setback 20 ft; max height 35 ft; max coverage 50% § 17.20.040
I‑L development highlights Min lot area 40,000 sq ft; front setback 15 ft; special 50 ft yard where abuts residential § 17.26.040
R‑1 development highlights R‑1‑10: 10,000 sq ft / front 20 ft; R‑1‑20: 20,000 sq ft / front 30 ft; R‑1‑40: 40,000 sq ft / front 30 ft; max coverage 50% § 17.14.040

Practical guidance / plain‑English synthesis

  • Prove lawfulness first. The city protects only uses/structures that were lawfully established before the code change; anything that was illegal before cannot become a legal nonconformity by the current code — see § 17.02.060 and § 17.48.020.
  • Small repairs allowed; big structural changes are restricted. Minor nonstructural maintenance is fine; structural repairs or additions to a nonconforming building typically require review (Community Development Director or planning commission) or a CUP — § 17.48.040 and § 17.48.080(B).
  • Don't "park and wait": if your nonconforming use stops for six months, you lose the right to resume it — § 17.48.060.
  • If your nonconforming building is damaged heavily (>60%), rebuilding must meet current zoning — § 17.48.070.
  • Expansion requires a discretionary approval: expand the use only via a CUP — § 17.48.080(A) referencing § 17.50.020.
  • ADU applicants: the city will not require correction of unrelated nonconforming zoning conditions as an ADU condition — Chapter 17.57 (ADU nonconformities). Scotts Valley ADUs

Linkages you will often need during a project: Scotts Valley Parking for parking compliance issues triggered by additions; Scotts Valley Development Standards and Scotts Valley Overlay Districts when a site sits in overlays; use Scotts Valley Variances and Exceptions when strict application is impractical.

Checklist (what an applicant must satisfy / bring)

  • Document that the use or structure was lawfully established prior to the effective date of the controlling ordinance (identify date and evidence). See § 17.04.170 and § 17.48.020.
  • For any structural alteration/addition: prepare full plans and submit the application form to the Planning Department; expect review by the Community Development Director and possible referral to the Planning Commission per § 17.48.080(B).
  • If seeking to expand a nonconforming use: prepare a Conditional Use Permit application per § 17.48.080(A) and § 17.50.020 standards.
  • If the use has ceased, verify continuous operation history; if cessation exceeds 6 months, the nonconforming right may be lost per § 17.48.060.
  • If a building was damaged, document the replacement value and date of damage; follow § 17.48.070 timelines for restoration or reconstruction.
  • For lot‑line adjustments touching nonconforming structures/uses: prepare an LLA demonstrating the adjustment does not increase nonconformity or that the adjustment eliminates nonconformity — § 17.48.090.
  • If the project affects parking demand or triggers parking nonconformity, consult Scotts Valley Parking and § 17.44.030; parking shortfalls on a nonconforming building may require review.

Risks & Ambiguities

Issue Why it matters What to verify
Was the use “lawful” originally? Nonconforming protection applies only to lawfully established uses; unlawful prior uses gain no protection. Verify records, permits, business licenses, dated photos or utility records; inspect § 17.02.060 and § 17.48.020.
Temporary cessation vs. permanent abandonment 6 months abandonment rule can terminate rights — loss of nonconforming status affects reuse or permitting. Document continuous use; if near 6 months of inactivity, seek staff guidance. See § 17.48.060.
Extent of “structural” repairs allowed Structural repairs beyond maintenance may trigger CUP or require bringing structure into conformance. Confirm whether work is “ordinary nonstructural” or structural; consult § 17.48.040 and building officials.
Damage threshold for reconstruction If > 60% damaged, rebuilding must meet current zoning — costly if noncompliant. Obtain qualified damage valuation and consult § 17.48.070 before reconstruction.
ADU interplay with nonconforming zoning ADU approvals cannot be conditioned on correcting unrelated nonconforming zoning conditions, per ADU chapter — but safety/public‑health exceptions exist. Rely on Chapter 17.57 ADU rules and provide building/fire compliance documentation. Scotts Valley ADUs
Parking shortfalls tied to nonconforming structure Additions may increase parking demand triggering review or design review conditions. Confirm parking standards and off‑street requirements in § 17.44.030 and consult planning staff. Scotts Valley Parking
Parcel‑specific mapping/overlays Overlay rules or combining districts may add or alter requirements for nonconforming resolution. Check zoning map and overlay chapters (ST, HR, HE, etc.) and consult § 17.36/§ 17.38. Scotts Valley Overlay Districts

Plain‑English Summary

If your property or business in Scotts Valley predates a zoning change, the city may allow the existing use or building to continue as a legal nonconformity, but you cannot expand that use without discretionary approval, you lose the nonconforming right if the use stops for six months, and major damage (over 60% of replacement value) forces you to rebuild to current rules. For repairs, small fixes are okay, structural work usually needs review, and accessory dwelling unit approvals generally cannot be conditioned on correcting unrelated zoning nonconformities. See § 17.48 and the related district chapters noted above.

Source References

  • Title 17 — Zoning, City of Scotts Valley (print export). Key local sections referenced below are from that source (Scotts Valley Municipal Code, Title 17):

    • § 17.48.010–090 (Chapter: Nonconforming Uses, Structures and Lots) — general purpose, continuation, repairs/alterations, change of use, cessation, restoration, expansion, lot line adjustments.
    • § 17.04.170 (Definitions: “Nonconforming use, lawful” and “Nonconforming structure, lawful”).
    • § 17.48.060 (Cessation / LPG amortization language).
    • § 17.48.070 (Restoration of damaged structures).
    • § 17.48.080 (Expansion of legal nonconforming uses and structures — CUP requirement and Community Dev Director review).
    • § 17.48.090 (Lot line adjustments involving nonconforming uses/structures).
    • § 17.20.010–040 (C‑S district purpose, prohibited uses and development standards).
    • § 17.26.020 / 17.26.040 (I‑L district permitted uses and development standards).
    • § 17.14.020 / 17.14.040 (R‑1 permitted uses and detailed development standards including R‑1‑10 / R‑1‑20 / R‑1‑40).
    • Table 17.46‑1 and accessory structure standards (height, setbacks, floor area notes and equivalencies for R‑M/R‑H/R‑VH) — see Table and notes.
    • Chapter 17.57 (Accessory Dwelling Units) — ADU rules including the explicit nonconformities clause and ADU development standards and parking exemptions.
    • Chapter 17.50 (Administrative procedures, CUP and appeal procedures) — CUP standards and appeal process for discretionary approvals referenced by Chapter 17.48.

  • State context on ADUs and nonconforming zoning (for interpretation of ADU‑related nonconforming limits) — ADU guidance material included in the uploaded files (2025 ADU handbook), used only as context where the local ADU chapter echoes state law.

Sources

Retrieved passages

  • CFC § 1 (Article 82) High relevance
  • CBC § 1 (§ 1) High relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (§ 1) High relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (title to) High relevance
  • CFC § 1 (Section 17.50.020) High relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (§ 1) High relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (Section 17.47.040A) High relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (§ 1) High relevance
  • CFC § 18007 (Section 18007) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (Section 65660.) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (Section 17.50.020) Medium relevance
  • CFC § 17.57.060 (Section 17.57.060.C) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (Chapter 17.48) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (§ 66314) Medium relevance
  • CBC § 000 Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (§ 1) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (Section 17.46.080) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (Section 17.44.030J.) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (Section 17.44.030J.) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (§ 4) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (§ 1) Medium relevance
  • CBC § 69 (Chapter 17.40.) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (chapter and) Medium relevance
  • Scotts Valley Zoning Code (Section 17.46.070.L.) Medium relevance

Cited sections

Frequently asked questions

What counts as a lawful nonconforming use or structure in Scotts Valley?

A lawful nonconforming use or structure is one that was lawfully established and maintained prior to the adoption or amendment of Title 17 and which no longer conforms to the current zoning regulations; the definitions are in § 17.04.170 and continuation of existing lawful nonconformities is covered in § 17.48.020.

If my business stopped operating for a while, can I restart it as a nonconforming use?

Not necessarily — if the nonconforming use of the building or land has ceased for six continuous months or more, it may not be re‑established as a nonconforming use under § 17.48.060. Verify continuous operation records with the City.

Can I rebuild after a fire or earthquake and keep the pre‑existing use?

If the nonconforming building was damaged more than 60% of its then reasonable replacement value, reconstruction must conform to current zoning rules; if less than 60%, restoration may proceed if started within 6 months and completed within 1 year, per § 17.48.070.

May I expand a nonconforming commercial use or add floor area?

Expanding a legal nonconforming use requires a Conditional Use Permit — Chapter 17.48 expressly limits expansions and references the CUP standards in § 17.50.020. For structural additions to a nonconforming building the Community Development Director reviews the building permit and may refer to the Planning Commission (§ 17.48.080).

If I subdivide or adjust lot lines, can that increase a nonconforming condition?

Lot‑line adjustments are allowed only when the adjustment does not increase the nonconformity (or is necessary to eliminate a nonconforming structure), per § 17.48.090; the Community Development Director may forward such applications to the Planning Commission.

Are ADUs treated differently where there are existing nonconforming conditions?

Yes — the ADU chapter states the city shall not require correction of nonconforming zoning conditions on the property as a condition of ADU approval (see Chapter 17.57). But the ADU must still meet ADU standards and building/fire safety rules. Scotts Valley ADUs

What happens to outlawed uses like some outdoor storage or LPG bulk storage?

The code contains targeted prohibitions and amortization schedules (for example, LPG bulk storage in commercial zones had a two‑year amortization tied to a 2011 effective date); check the specific district language and amortization clauses in § 17.48.060(C) and district chapters. Verify amortization applicability to your parcel.

How do parking requirements affect changes to a nonconforming structure?

If a nonconforming structure is nonconforming because of parking, adding floor area can trigger additional parking requirements and referral to the Planning Commission; the Community Development Director will evaluate parking impact per § 17.48.080(B) and off‑street parking rules in Chapter 17.44. Scotts Valley Parking

Do dimensional standards for my R‑1 lot change if I have an accessory structure already in a nonconforming location?

Accessory structure standards in Table 17.46‑1 and the R‑1 development standards in § 17.14.040 govern accessory structure size, setbacks and height; some accessory structures under 120 sq ft and under 8 ft have relaxed rear/interior side setbacks, otherwise they follow primary structure setbacks. See Table 17.46‑1 and § 17.14.040.

Can the City require I bring a damaged nonconforming building into full compliance with current setbacks and coverage during a repair?

If the damage exceeds 60% of replacement value, the code requires restoration to conform to the zoning district's current regulations; for less damage, repairs can proceed under timelines in § 17.48.070. Consult the Community Development Director early.

More in Scotts Valley code

Ask about any Scotts Valley property

Get a cited, plain-English answer on Scotts Valley zoning, setbacks, FAR, ADUs and permits — for any address.

Start Free Trial

More Scotts Valley zoning topics

Scotts Valley Zoning

Scotts Valley Land Use

Scotts Valley Development Standards

Scotts Valley Parking

Scotts Valley Design Review

Scotts Valley Overlay Districts

Scotts Valley Historic Preservation

Scotts Valley Signage

Scotts Valley Variances and Exceptions

Scotts Valley Landscaping and Screening

Scotts Valley overview