San Mateo — 2023 Civil Trial Verdicts

Source: https://sanmateo.courts.ca.gov/system/files/civil/civil_trial_verdicts_2023-updated-041724.pdf

Civil Case Verdict Report VF Event from 1/1/2023 to 12/31/2023

Case Nbr Style Case Type Judgment Date Judgment Type VF event Plaintiff Attorney Defendant Attorney Cross Complainant Attorney Cross Defendant Judgment Detail Judgment Comment

CIV536273 ELIAS MENDOZA vs Complex Civil Unlimited 5/10/2023 Jury Verdict 04/20/2023 * KERLEY, J * KELLEY, RACHAEL K. BURTON, PLAINTIFFS ELIAS MENDOZA AND PACIFIC SPECIALTY INSURANCE COMPANY Class Action EDWARDSCHAFFER, DYLAN L. MICHELLE L PRISCILA MENDOZA TAKE A CORPORATION CARLING, CHRISTOPHER MADDOCK, JAHNE' Monetary Award NOTHING FROM DEFENDNAT NANDIVADA, HARITA SHOECRAFT, DEVIN T • Awarded To: PACIFIC SPECIALTY PACIFIC SPECIALTY INSURANCE * KERLEY, J INSURANCE COMPANY A CORPORATION COMPANY. DEFENDANT PACIFIC EDWARDSCHAFFER, DYLAN L. • Was no judgment awarded?: SPECIALTY INSURANCE COMPANY CARLING, CHRISTOPHER • Judgment Amount: HAVE AND RECOVER FROM NANDIVADA, HARITA • And Attorney Fee: PLAINTIFFS THE SUM OF COSTS • Awarded Against: MENDOZA, ELIAS UPON A TIMELY SERVICE AND MENDOZA, PRISCILA FILING OF A MEMORANDUM OF • Was there a judgment amount?: COSTS. SEE JUDGMENT FILED ON 5/10/2023. • Damage: • pre-judgment interest rate: • pre-judgment interest: • Attorney Fee:

• Attorney Fee:

• Attorney Fee:
• Cost:
• Other:
• Other comment:
• Status: Active
• Status Date: 05/10/2023

• Status Date: 05/10/2023

17-CIV-05387 FRANCESCA FAMBROUGH, et al vs. (26) Unlimited Other Real 10/19/2023 Court Finding 10/12/2023 * FROSTROM, KAREN * BLUM, MAXWELL SIEGEL, PLEASE SEE JUDGMENT BY COURT CITY OF REDWOOD CITY Property R.BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR KEVIN D. AFTER PHASE ONE * FROSTROM, KAREN R. TONG, ALBERT Monetary Award COURT TRIAL AND PHASE TWO JURY BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR RAMIREZ, VERONICA • Awarded To: Chambers, John • Was no TRIAL FILED 10/19/2023 FOR * Pro Se judgment awarded?: JUDGMENT DETAILS. * FROSTROM, KAREN • Judgment Amount: R.BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR • And Attorney Fee: * FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Awarded Against: CITY OF REDWOOD BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * CITY FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Was there a judgment amount?: Y BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • Damage: 79,283.00 FROSTROM, KAREN R. • pre-judgment interest rate: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • pre-judgment interest: FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Attorney Fee: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • Cost: FROSTROM, KAREN R.

ROM, KAREN R.

ROM, KAREN R. • Other: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR • Other comment: • Status: Satisfied • Status Date: 11/29/2023

• Status Date: 11/29/2023

17-CIV-05387 FRANCESCA FAMBROUGH, et al vs. (26) Unlimited Other Real 10/19/2023 Court Finding 10/12/2023 * FROSTROM, KAREN * BLUM, MAXWELL PLEASE SEE JUDGMENT BY CITY OF REDWOOD CITY Property R.BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR SIEGEL, KEVIN D. TONG, COURT AFTER PHASE ONE * FROSTROM, KAREN R. ALBERT Monetary Award COURT TRIAL AND PHASE TWO JURY BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR RAMIREZ, VERONICA • Awarded To: Humphries, Jedrick TRIAL FILED 10/19/2023 FOR * Pro Se • Was no judgment awarded?: JUDGMENT DETAILS. * FROSTROM, KAREN • Judgment Amount: R.BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR • And Attorney Fee: * FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Awarded Against: CITY OF REDWOOD BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * CITY FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Was there a judgment amount?: Y BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • Damage: 56,090.00 FROSTROM, KAREN R. • pre-judgment interest rate: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • pre-judgment interest: FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Attorney Fee: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • Cost: FROSTROM, KAREN R.

• Cost: FROSTROM, KAREN R.

• Cost: FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Other: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR • Other comment: • Status: Active • Status Date: 10/19/2023

• Status Date: 10/19/2023

17-CIV-05387 FRANCESCA FAMBROUGH, et al vs. (26) Unlimited Other Real 10/19/2023 Court Finding 10/12/2023 * FROSTROM, KAREN * BLUM, MAXWELL SIEGEL, PLEASE SEE JUDGMENT BY COURT CITY OF REDWOOD CITY Property R.BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR KEVIN D. AFTER PHASE ONE * FROSTROM, KAREN R. TONG, ALBERT Monetary Award COURT TRIAL AND PHASE TWO JURY BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR RAMIREZ, VERONICA • Awarded To: Stancil, Edward • Was no TRIAL FILED 10/19/2023 FOR * Pro Se judgment awarded?: JUDGMENT DETAILS. * FROSTROM, KAREN • Judgment Amount: R.BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR • And Attorney Fee: * FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Awarded Against: CITY OF REDWOOD BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * CITY FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Was there a judgment amount?: Y BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • Damage: 116,550.00 FROSTROM, KAREN R. • pre-judgment interest rate: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • pre-judgment interest: FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Attorney Fee: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • Cost: FROSTROM, KAREN R.

STROM, KAREN R.

STROM, KAREN R. • Other: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR • Other comment: • Status: Active • Status Date: 10/19/2023

3/7/2024 4:17:13 PM

17-CIV-05387 FRANCESCA FAMBROUGH, et al vs. (26) Unlimited Other Real 10/19/2023 Court Finding 10/12/2023 * FROSTROM, KAREN * BLUM, MAXWELL PLEASE SEE JUDGMENT BY CITY OF REDWOOD CITY Property R.BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR SIEGEL, KEVIN D. TONG, COURT AFTER PHASE ONE * FROSTROM, KAREN R. ALBERT Monetary Award COURT TRIAL AND PHASE TWO BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR RAMIREZ, VERONICA • Awarded To: PESCHCKE-KOEDT, NINA JURY TRIAL FILED 10/19/2023 FOR * Pro Se • Was no judgment awarded?: JUDGMENT DETAILS. * FROSTROM, KAREN • Judgment Amount: R.BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR • And Attorney Fee: * FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Awarded Against: CITY OF REDWOOD BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * CITY FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Was there a judgment amount?: Y BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • Damage: 93,950.00 FROSTROM, KAREN R. • pre-judgment interest rate: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • pre-judgment interest: FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Attorney Fee: BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR * • Cost: FROSTROM, KAREN R. • Other:

• Other:

• Other:

BARTOLOTTA, VINCENT J., JR • Other comment: • Status: Active • Status Date: 10/19/2023

• Status Date: 10/19/2023

18-CIV-03290 PROUD THAI MASSAGE LLC, a limited (06) Unlimited Breach of 2/16/2024 Jury Verdict 12/14/2023 * SIMHAYOFF-COEHN, SARIT * * MENGARELLI, * MENGARELLI, PLEASE SEE JUDGMENT FILED liability company, et al vs. Contract/Warranty SIMHAYOFF-COEHN, SARIT MICHAEL* STREZA, DAVID J. MICHAEL* STREZA, DAVID 02/16/2024 FOR DETAILS ALEX ABELA, et al SMITH, CHARLES J. * STREZA, DAVID J. Monetary Award J.STREZA, DAVID J. * STREZA, DAVID • Awarded To: ABELA, ALEX ALEX J. ABELA PROPERTIES, INC. BEST SELLER LTD. * STREZA, DAVID J. STREZA, DAVID J. ONATE, EMANUEL KELLY, RICHARD M. ONATE, MARIANNE * STREZA, DAVID J. • Was no judgment awarded?: KELLY, RICHARD M. • Judgment Amount: • And Attorney Fee: • Awarded Against: MAYER, ALEXANDER PROUD THAI MASSAGE LLC, a limited liability company

company

company
• Was there a judgment amount?: Y
• Damage:
• pre-judgment interest rate:
• pre-judgment interest:
• Attorney Fee:
• Cost:
• Other:
• Other comment:
• Status: Active
• Status Date: 02/16/2024

• Status Date: 02/16/2024

18-CIV-06036 ALISSA GULER vs. (22) Unlimited Auto 8/31/2023 Jury Verdict 08/21/2023 * STOLL, ALBERT G., JR * CAPABIANCO, JENNIFER J. PLEASE SEE JUDGMENT FILED ZAKI FARS, et al MCKIE, RICHARD D 08/31/2023 FOR ADDITIONAL GARCIA, RICHARD Monetary and Non-Monetary Award • JUDGMENT DETAILS. * CAPABIANCO, JENNIFER J. Awarded To: TRUCK, SCOOBEEZ MCKIE, RICHARD D GARCIA, • Was no judgment awarded?: RICHARD • Judgment Amount: • And Attorney Fee: • Awarded Against: GULER, ALISSA • Was there a judgment amount?: Y • Damage: • pre-judgment interest rate: • pre-judgment interest: • Attorney Fee: • Cost: • Other: • Other comment:

• Other comment:

• Other comment:
• Status: Active
• Status Date: 08/31/2023

• Status Date: 08/31/2023

19-CIV-03505 GISELLE ALEXANDRA DIAZ MURILLO (22) Unlimited Auto 7/7/2023 Jury Verdict 06/22/2023 * MOHRMAN, GREGORY R. * COKE, WILLIAM H. SEE JUDGMENT ON SPECIAL vs. CARESS, JAMES * COKE, WILLIAM H. VERDICT FILED ON 7/7/23. Monetary Award STEVE CAMPOS PEREZ, et al BEECHER, BRIAN GORDON • Awarded To: MURILLO, GISELLE ALEXANDRA DIAZ • Was no judgment awarded?: • Judgment Amount: • And Attorney Fee: • Awarded Against: PEREZ, STEVE CAMPOS • Was there a judgment amount?: Y • Damage: 2,100,000.00 • pre-judgment interest rate: • pre-judgment interest: • Attorney Fee: • Cost:

• Cost:

• Cost: • Other: • Other comment: • Status: Active • Status Date: 07/07/2023

3/7/2024 4:17:13 PM

20-CIV-01267 GARY GREEN vs. (07) Unlimited Business 3/15/2023 Jury Verdict 02/22/2023 * KLINGSPORN, GREGORY K. * LARSEN, RYAN PLAINTIFF GARY GREEN SHALL TAKE EQUINIX INC., et al Tort/Unfair Business BEYERS, JENNIFER A. WEINER, JOEL R BRINES, NOTHING FROM DEFENDANT PACKET Practice GRIMM, RICHARD ASHLEY T. HOST. INC. BY REASON OF HIS SECOND * LARSEN, AMENDED COMPLAINT. RYANBRINES, ASHLEY T. * Non-Monetary Award LARSEN, RYAN • Awarded To: Packet Host, Inc. • Was no WEINER, JOEL R judgment awarded?: BRINES, ASHLEY T. • Judgment Amount: • And Attorney Fee: • Awarded Against: GREEN, GARY • Was there a judgment amount?: Y • Damage: • pre-judgment interest rate: • pre-judgment interest: • Attorney Fee: • Cost: • Other:

• Other:

• Other:
• Other comment:
• Status: Active
• Status Date: 03/15/2023

• Status Date: 03/15/2023

20-CIV-03255 Christopher Kidwell vs. (22) Unlimited Auto 1/4/2024 Jury Verdict 09/06/2023 * ROACH, JOHN J. * CASEY, ARTHUR J. PLEASE SEE AMENDED Sally Evans, et al JUDGMENT ON JURY VERDICT Monetary Award FILED 01/04/2024 FOR ADDITIONAL • Awarded To: Kidwell, Christopher JUDGMENT DETAILS • Was no judgment awarded?: • Judgment Amount: 100,000.00 • And Attorney Fee: • Awarded Against: Evans, Sally • Was there a judgment amount?: Y • Damage: 100,000.00 • pre-judgment interest rate: • pre-judgment interest: • Attorney Fee: • Cost: 30,284.98 • Other:

• Other:

• Other: • Other comment: • Status: Satisfied • Status Date: 01/19/2024

• Status Date: 01/19/2024

20-CIV-03255 Christopher Kidwell vs. (22) Unlimited Auto 9/29/2023 Jury Verdict 09/06/2023 * ROACH, JOHN J. * CASEY, ARTHUR J. PLEASE SEE JUDGMENT ON JURY Sally Evans, et al VERDICT FILED 09/29/2023 FOR Monetary Award ADDITIONAL JUDGMENT DETAILS • Awarded To: Kidwell, Christopher • Was no judgment awarded?: • Judgment Amount: 100,000.00 • And Attorney Fee: • Awarded Against: Evans, Sally • Was there a judgment amount?: Y • Damage: 100,000.00 • pre-judgment interest rate: • pre-judgment interest: • Attorney Fee: • Cost: • Other:

• Other:

• Other: • Other comment: • Status: Active • Status Date: 09/29/2023

20-CIV-02801 RAIKHAN ABDYKULOVA (23) Unlimited Other PI/PD/WD 10/23/2023 CIENFUEGOS, P. DAVID REINHOLTZ, JACK R IJAMS, REINHOLTZ, JACK R IJAMS, CIENFUEGOS, P. DAVID vs. KLEIN, ROBERT MAX HEATHER HEATHER KLEIN, ROBERT MAX TISHMAN SPEYER ARCHSTONE-SMITH WONG, ALISTER S ROSE, ASHLEY DAWN ROSE, ASHLEY DAWN WONG, ALISTER S REDWOOD SHORES L.L.C., a Delaware WILLIS, ROBERT WILLIS, ROBERT limited liability company, et al

20-CIV-03436 Michael Williams, et al vs. (25) Unlimited Professional 10/10/2023 SUSSMAN, JORDAN A. BRADEN, JAMES M. BRADEN, JAMES M. SUSSMAN, JORDAN A. Jonathan Rui, et al Negligence BRADEN, JAMES M. FLEER, JOHN L FLEER, JOHN L SABHARWAL, SUNENA SABHARWAL, SUNENA SABHARWAL, SUNENA SUSSMAN, JORDAN A. SUSSMAN, JORDAN A.

20-CIV-03436 Michael Williams, et al vs. (25) Unlimited Professional 10/10/2023 SUSSMAN, JORDAN A. BRADEN, JAMES M. BRADEN, JAMES M. SUSSMAN, JORDAN A. Zero to Plaintiff and Zero to Defendant Jonathan Rui, et al Negligence BRADEN, JAMES M. FLEER, JOHN L FLEER, JOHN L SABHARWAL, SUNENA SABHARWAL, SUNENA SABHARWAL, SUNENA SUSSMAN, JORDAN A. SUSSMAN, JORDAN A.

3/7/2024 4:17:13 PM